Key Points to Consider When Choosing an Electronic Seal Provider
- Choose the right level of electronic seal—simple, advanced, or qualified—based on your organization’s legal requirements and security needs.
- Verify the provider’s security measures: protection of cryptographic keys, certificate management, access control, and transaction traceability.
- Prioritize a solution that’s easy to integrate: a well-documented API and a testing environment facilitate the automation of digital signing within business applications.
- Plan for volume and costs: performance, service availability, and the pricing model must be tailored to current and future needs.
- Ensuring the verifiability of documents over time: Combining an electronic seal with a qualified timestamp strengthens the evidentiary guarantees regarding the date and integrity of the data.
1. Verify the security level and legal safeguards of the electronic seal
The first step is to determine the level of security and legal safeguards your organization requires.
The European eIDAS Regulation distinguishes between several levels of electronic seals: simple, advanced, and qualified. The choice depends, in particular, on the sensitivity of the documents, the risk of disputes, and any regulatory obligations applicable to your business.
Article 35 of the eIDAS Regulation provides that an electronic seal may not be denied legal effect or rejected as evidence solely on the grounds that it is not a qualified electronic seal. A qualified electronic seal, however, benefits from specific legal presumptions regarding the integrity of the data and the accuracy of its origin.
It is therefore important to verify the level of the proposed digital seal, the characteristics of the certificate used, and the guarantees actually associated with the service. If your business requires a qualified digital seal, make sure the solution meets the requirements set forth by eIDAS and verify the status of the relevant services in the European trusted lists.
Combining an electronic seal with a qualified time stamp can also strengthen the document’s evidentiary value. The document is presumed to accurately reflect the date and time indicated, and the integrity of the time-stamped data is presumed to be intact.
2. Review security measures and certificate management
The reliability of an electronic seal service also depends on the security measures implemented by the provider.
Several elements deserve special attention:
- Protection of cryptographic keys: How are they generated, stored, and protected against unauthorized access?
- Certificate management: What procedures govern their issuance, renewal, and revocation?
- Access control: Which individuals or applications are authorized to apply a seal on behalf of the organization?
- Operation traceability: Does the provider allow users to retrieve information related to each stamping operation?
Security certifications, particularly ISO 27001, are also useful indicators for evaluating a service provider’s practices.
One point deserves special attention: the identity associated with the seal. Depending on the solution chosen, the document can be sealed in the name of your organization or by a trusted third party. This distinction must be considered based on the intended use.
3. Evaluate how easily it integrates with your IT systems
For companies that regularly produce digital documents, the electronic seal must be able to integrate directly into existing applications.
A provider offering an electronic stamp API allows you to automate the application of stamps from an ERP system, invoicing software, an EDM system, or a line-of-business application, without requiring manual intervention for each transaction.
Before selecting your service provider, be sure to check the following:
- The availability of an API and the quality of its technical documentation.
- The existence of a test environment (sandbox).
- Compatibility with the document formats used by your organization.
- The availability of an SDK and code samples to facilitate development.
Ease of integration is particularly important for software vendors who want to offer electronic signatures directly to their users.
A provider capable of supporting technical teams starting in the testing phase also helps reduce deployment time and costs.
4. Verify the provider’s ability to handle your document volumes
Electronic sealing needs vary considerably from one organization to another.
A company that secures a few dozen contracts per month does not face the same constraints as a software vendor or platform that issues several thousand invoices, certificates, or attestations every day.
It is therefore important to evaluate the solution’s ability not only to handle current volumes but also to scale with future growth.
The key points to examine are API performance, processing times, the ability to handle traffic spikes, and service level agreements (SLAs).
A provider suited for high-volume environments must also offer mechanisms for monitoring operations and managing errors, in order to limit the impact of an outage on business processes.
5. Ensure the verifiability of timestamps and the long-term preservation of evidence
Applying an electronic seal is just the first step. The recipient must still be able to verify its validity, and the information needed for that verification must remain accessible over time.
The provider must enable users to verify the integrity of the document, identify the issuer associated with the seal, and verify the information regarding the certificate used.
This issue becomes particularly important when documents are retained for several years.
An electronic certificate has a limited validity period. The ability to verify a document over the long term depends, in particular, on the retention of validation information and the preservation mechanisms put in place.
A qualified time stamp serves as a complementary measure. It allows a date and time to be associated with the data, thereby qualifying for the presumptions set forth in Article 41 of the eIDAS Regulation.
However, it does not replace the validation and archiving mechanisms necessary for verifying time stamps.
For documents that may be presented during an audit, a regulatory inspection, or a legal dispute, these characteristics must be included in the criteria for selecting a provider.
6. Compare Rates and Billing Models
The price of an electronic seal service generally depends on the volume of documents to be processed, the features offered, and the provider’s contractual terms.
Several pricing models can be considered: per-document billing, a monthly flat fee, an annual subscription, or volume-based tiered pricing.
When comparing offers, it’s best to consider the overall cost of the solution, not just the price per stamp.
Certain costs may be added to the initial price, such as setup fees, certificate acquisition or renewal, technical support, time-stamping, or verification features.
It’s also helpful to review the contract’s scalability terms as your volume increases.
An offer tailored to your needs should allow you to anticipate expenses while avoiding additional costs associated with each change in your business.
7. Evaluate technical assistance and the quality of support
The quality of support is a final selection criterion, particularly when the electronic seal must be integrated into existing business processes.
In addition to providing an API, the service provider must be able to answer technical questions, assist the teams during deployment, and step in if any issues arise.
Before choosing a provider, find out about the support terms, availability hours, response times, and services included in the contract.
The provider’s regulatory expertise can also be helpful in choosing a configuration that meets the requirements of your industry.
Questions to Ask Before Choosing Your Electronic Signature Provider
To make it easier to compare different providers, here is a summary of the key points to check.
| Criterion | Questions to Ask the Supplier |
|---|---|
| Legal Guarantees | What level of seal do you offer? What eIDAS guarantees are associated with the service? |
| Security | How do you protect cryptographic keys and manage certificates? |
| Technical Integration | Do you have a documented API and a test environment? |
| Performance | What volumes can you handle, and what are your availability commitments? |
| Verifiability | How can stamps be verified and their validity maintained over time? |
| Pricing | What fees are included, and how does the price change based on volume? |
| Support | What technical and regulatory support do you offer? |
These questions will help you structure your evaluation and identify any differences between the offerings, beyond just the features presented.
Why choose Evidency as your electronic seal provider?
Evidency offers an electronic seal solution designed to secure documents issued by organizations and integrate directly with their business processes.
The service allows you to apply an electronic seal to PDF documents, either in the name of Evidency as a trusted third party or in the name of your organization using an appropriate certificate.
Each stamp is associated with a qualified timestamp issued by Evidency, a Trust Service Provider qualified by ANSSI for its timestamping service, in accordance with the eIDAS Regulation.
The solution is accessible via a REST API and includes technical documentation, SDKs, and a sandbox environment to facilitate integration.
It also offers a flat-rate pricing plan tailored to document volumes, with no setup fees and support included.
FAQ: Choosing an Electronic Seal Provider
How can you verify that an electronic seal provider is eIDAS-qualified?
It is important to distinguish between the provider’s qualification and that of the services it offers. European trusted lists allow you to verify qualified providers and the services covered by their qualification.
A provider qualified for time-stamping does not necessarily offer a qualified electronic seal service.
Can an electronic seal be integrated directly into business software?
Yes. Providers that offer an API allow you to automate the application of stamps from an ERP, an EDM system, invoicing software, or an in-house application. It is recommended that you verify the availability of a test environment and technical documentation before selecting a solution.
Disclaimer of liability
The opinions, presentations, figures and estimates presented on the website, including the blog, are for information purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice. For legal advice, you should contact a legal professional in your jurisdiction.
The use of the content of this website, including the blog, for commercial purposes, including resale, is prohibited without prior authorization from Evidency. The request for permission must specify the purpose and extent of reproduction. For non-commercial purposes, all material in this publication may be freely quoted or reprinted, but acknowledgement is required, together with a link to this website.



